Why Your Best People Want You to Leave Them Alone
Richer Soul Podcast • Episode 503 • Nathan Jamail
Here is a question worth asking before you read any further.
Think about the people who report to you. If you had to guess, honestly, what is their real professional goal? Not the answer they would give in a performance review. The real one.
Nathan Jamail has been asking that question in boardrooms, leadership workshops, and one-on-one coaching sessions for more than 20 years. He has coached leaders at Cisco, Hilton Hotels, State Farm, and Georgia Pacific. He built seven number-one producing teams during his tenure as an executive director at a Fortune 100 company. He teaches in the MBA program at SMU.
And what he keeps finding is this: 90% of employees, at every level, share the same professional goal. To be so good their boss leaves them alone.
That is not just a stat. It is a mirror.
What “Leave Me Alone” Actually Tells You
Nathan is not using this number to criticize employees. He is using it to ask leaders a harder question.
“If that is the goal,” he told Rocky in this conversation, “then how are you valuable?”
Most leaders interpret their value as solving problems. They spend their coaching time, their calendar, their attention on the people who are struggling. The logic feels right: these are the people who need help. But the unintended consequence is that the message sent to high performers is unmistakable. Perform well and you will be left alone. Struggle and your leader shows up.
So high performers learn to perform well enough to avoid attention. They plateau. Not from lack of ambition, but because they have figured out that attention is a consequence, not a resource.
“Most leaders work with the employees who need the attention instead of those who deserve the attention,” Nathan said. That single reframe is the entry point for what he teaches, and it asks something uncomfortable: who is actually getting your calendar right now?
The Real Coaching Gap
Nathan has written several books on leadership, including “The Leadership Playbook” and “Serve Up Coach Down.” But the idea at the center of all of them is the same.
Corporate America is structured around a contradiction. Leaders are asked to coach their people. But leaders are almost never taught how to coach. They are promoted for being excellent at something else, usually sales or engineering or operations, and then handed a team and told to develop them.
“We ask our leaders to coach their employees,” Nathan said, “yet we never teach them how to be coaches.”
The result is that most leaders manage the way they were managed, which is to say they manage by reacting. They show up when something breaks. They check boxes. They run one-on-ones that function as status updates rather than skill-building conversations. And their best people, reading the room correctly, calibrate their behavior to need less.
This is not a motivation problem. It is an architectural one. The building is designed to reward the wrong thing.
The Leader in the Middle
One of the most specific arguments Nathan makes in this conversation is about organizational alignment, and about where alignment breaks down.
Most discussions about the gap between leadership and the front line focus on the people at the top and the people at the bottom. Nathan’s argument is that the most consequential figure sits between them.
He calls this person the leader in the middle. The director. The senior manager. The person who receives strategy from above and translates it downward, and who receives reality from the front line and translates it upward.
“They are the most powerful leaders in the organization,” Nathan said. “They determine the success and failure of everything from alignment to execution.”
The problem is that translation never happens neutrally. A vice president passes down a directive. The director adds their own interpretation. The manager adds theirs. By the time it reaches the person doing the work, the original intent has been processed through three different filters, each one shaped by a different set of priorities and insecurities.
“What we have,” Nathan said, “is we try to get people’s buy-in instead of their belief.”
Buy-in is compliance. People do the thing because they have agreed to do the thing. Belief is different. People do the thing because they understand why it matters and they trust the person asking. Buy-in disappears the moment the stakes get high or the inconvenience gets real. Belief holds.
What AI Will Reveal
Nathan was asked about AI’s impact on leadership, and his answer was precise in a way that most answers on this topic are not.
Knowledge, he said, is no longer a competitive advantage. It is table stakes. Any salesperson who tries to differentiate themselves by knowing more than the buyer is already behind.
What AI cannot do is build trust. It cannot make a genuine connection. It cannot get a human being to commit to something they are resisting, not through logic alone. And it cannot mandate alignment by caring about the outcome.
“If AI is in charge of developing your people,” Nathan said, “as a leader, you will be gone.”
The inverse is also true. The leader who has been developing people through genuine coaching, precise expectations, and real accountability has just become harder to replace. The human work that most leaders have been avoiding, the uncomfortable conversation, the consistent follow-through, the belief in someone’s potential that has to be demonstrated rather than declared, that work is now the work that cannot be automated.
Rocky made a related point from his own practice. He uses AI as a sales coach, not to replace his thinking but to challenge it. He reviews his own conversations with AI, asking what he missed, what he could have asked differently, how he could have listened better. The AI surfaces possibilities. Rocky decides. The cognitive work stays human.
Nathan’s phrase for what Rocky is describing is scrimmaging, role-playing without judgment, not to test a person but to prepare them for the real conversation. It is a coaching method, and it is one that AI can facilitate but only a human can make meaningful.
Rocky’s Perspective
One of the things Rocky has arrived at, after years of watching organizations struggle with exactly this, is that most tools get applied the wrong way. Systems like EOS or Profit First get treated as the plan rather than as instruments for building one.
“I don’t have a cookbook,” he said in this conversation. “I have a whole wall of cookbooks. Because I know for this particular situation, in this book is a recipe that might help if we adapt it to you.”
That is a leadership philosophy as much as it is a business one. The tools are not the answer. The leader is the answer. The tools give the leader better questions to ask.
Nathan’s framework, at its core, is a way of asking better questions. Why do your best people want to be left alone? Who is getting your coaching time, and who deserves it? What does your middle leader believe, versus what have they merely agreed to?
These are not comfortable questions. They are the right ones.
One Question to Sit With
If the goal of your best people is to be left alone by you, what does that say about how your presence is being experienced?
About Nathan Jamail
Nathan Jamail is a record-setting performer, CEO, Adjunct Professor in the MBA program at SMU’s Cox School of Business, where he has earned more than 18 Teacher Excellence Awards, and a bestselling author of leadership and sales books. During his tenure as an Executive Director at a Fortune 100 company, Nathan built and led seven #1 producing teams across five states and Puerto Rico. He has also built, scaled, and sold multiple small businesses, bringing real-world corporate and entrepreneurial leadership experience to everything he teaches.
For more than two decades, Nathan has coached and developed leaders on three continents and thousands around the world. His leadership principles now serve as the backbone for organizations across manufacturing, finance, technology, communications, hospitality, and more. In a business climate shaped by AI acceleration and constant disruption, Nathan helps organizations leverage technology without losing their human edge, building teams that win through clarity, discipline, accountability, and trust.
Links
Email: info@nathanjamail.com
LinkedIn: @nathanjamail
https://www.linkedin.com/in/nathanjamail/
Facebook: @jdgroup
https://www.facebook.com/jdgroup
Instagram: @nathan_jamail
https://www.instagram.com/nathan_jamail
Watch the full episode on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@richersoul
Richer Soul Life Beyond Money. You got rich, now what? Let’s talk about your journey to purposeful, intentional, amazing life. Where are you going to go and how are you going to get there? Let’s figure that out together. At the core is the financial well being to be able to do what you want, when you want, how you want. It’s about personal freedom!
Thanks for listening!
Show Sponsor: http://profitcomesfirst.com/
Schedule your free no obligation call: https://bookme.name/rockyl/lite/intro appointment 15 minutes
If you like the show please leave a review on iTunes: http://bit.do/richersoul
https://www.facebook.com/richersoul
Some music provided by Junan from Junan Podcast
Any financial advice is for educational purposes only and you should consult with an expert for your specific needs.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: RSS
0 Comments